Smile.io charges $299–$999/mo and still requires a loyalty manager. PointPilot generates your entire program in 60 seconds for $49/mo — zero team required.
| Feature | PointPilot | Smile.io |
|---|---|---|
| AI-generated program design | ✓ Fully autonomous | ✗ Manual setup required |
| Time to launch | ✓ 60 seconds | ~ Days to weeks |
| Points & rewards tiers | ✓ AI-configured | ✓ Manual configuration |
| Custom reward catalog | ✓ Included | ✓ Paid plans only |
| ROI projections & analytics | ✓ Built-in AI projections | ~ Paid plans only |
| Launch checklist | ✓ Auto-generated | ✗ Not included |
| Team required to manage | ✓ Zero team needed | ✗ Loyalty manager recommended |
| Free program generation | ✓ Always free | ~ Free tier (very limited) |
| API access | ✓ Growth plan+ | ✓ Growth plan+ |
| Custom branding | ✓ Growth plan+ | ✓ Growth plan+ |
| Shopify-native integration | ~ API-based | ✓ Native |
| Industry-specific design | ✓ AI tailors to your vertical | ✗ Generic templates |
A typical Smile.io customer on the Growth plan pays $3,588/yr in software — plus a loyalty program manager at $60,000–$80,000/yr. That's $63,000–$83,000/yr just to run a loyalty program. PointPilot's Growth plan is $1,788/yr, with zero headcount required.
Generate a complete loyalty program with tiers, rewards, and ROI projections in 60 seconds. No credit card required.
Generate Your Program →Free to generate. $49/mo to activate.